Assessment denies disability benefit to woman with rare disease because she has a degree

NOTE: This post is relevant to all people with disabilities who may wish to claim PIP or ESA benefits. Read on whether your disability is a result of one of many diseases such as multiple sclerosis, Parkinson’s or another illness, or has another cause.


PIP assessments, and the people that carry them out, are flawed. We know that, even official papers released by the government show it.

Astoundingly, it now seems that assessors believe that more highly educated you are, the less you need to be paid disability benefit. What an absolutely crazy idea – as if education or a degree can have any effect on how we are affected by our disabilities.

Those of us with disabilities, whether caused by one of a number of illnesses or injury, won’t be surprised. We are used to absurdities of obtaining the appropriate benefits.

Having said that, before you doubt that assessors could be so stupid, one person’s case has already been talked about in the House of Commons. There, UK prime minister Theresa May expressed concern and promised it would be investigated.


Liz McKinnes MP

The case was brought up during prime minister’s questions last week by Liz McInnes, Labour MP for Heywood and Middleton. She spoke of her constituent, Natasha, who has fanconi anemia – a genetic bone marrow condition which carries a very high risk of cancer.

Degree: doesn’t need as much support

Ms McInnes said: “Natasha was on lifetime disability allowance (DLA), which was removed following a PIP assessment.

“When Natasha appealed, she was told that because she had a degree, she doesn’t need as much support.

“Now, I’m sure the PM is aware that disease and cancer are no respecters of qualifications and I’d like to ask the PM what urgent measures she will take to improve the quality and standard of PIP assessments.”

Theresa May, prime minister.

Mrs May admitted the case was concerning and surprising.

She said: “Obviously, the DWP is constantly looking at the standard of PIP assessments that are being made I’m sorry to hear the case that the Honorable Lady has set out.

“I’m sure most people would be concerned at hear that case. I’m very surprised at the judgement that was given in relation to that individual. Can I suggest that she sends in the detail of that case and we’ll make sure that that’s looked into.”

Well, I am sure Natasha’s case will be subject to an investigation, of sorts, but I don’t think it will lead to any major changes that could benefit the rest of us. No, that would be too much to hope from this government.

* * * * *

Affiliate disclaimer: This affiliate disclosure details the affiliate relationships of MS, Health & Disability at with other companies and products. Read more.

* * * * * is the personal website of Ian Franks, a freelance medical writer and editor for various health information sites. He enjoyed a successful career as a journalist, from reporter to editor in the print media. He gained a Journalist of the Year award in his native UK. Ian received a diagnosis of MS in 2002 and now lives in the south of Spain. He uses a wheelchair and advocates on mobility and accessibility issues.

* * * * *

Note: Health-related information available on 50shadesofsun website is intended for your general knowledge only and is not a substitute for medical advice or treatment for specific medical conditions. I am not a doctor and cannot and do not give you medical advice. You should seek prompt medical care for any specific health issues and consult a doctor before starting a new diet or exercise programme. Any opinions expressed are purely my own unless otherwise stated.



2 thoughts on “Assessment denies disability benefit to woman with rare disease because she has a degree

  1. I was denied Social Security the first time applied. I have MS and have my BA in Economics and an AS in nursing as a registeref nurse. I was told I could work. Being an RN you are ears and eyes of a doctor. To me, if i wasn’t a 100% i would not want that responsibility of someone’s life. Once I was seen by a Social Security doctor they sent me to, I won my appeal and was granted my Social Security Disability.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s